January 18, 2013

Right Age for Certain Books?

Jo Walton has an interesting post over at Tor.  In it, she asks about reading books "too early" or "too late."  I found it interesting because I think I received The Catcher in the Rye too early, then read it too late.  My parents always gave me some books for holidays and birthdays and I remember getting that distinctive maroon paperback before we moved away from Ohio, so sometime in my early teens.  I think I must have started it, but it is a unique voice and I guess I didn't take to it, so saved it for later.  I don't know when I finally got around to it, but I'm pretty sure it was after college.

There must be a window of time in your late teens when it grabs you, because while I appreciated it and really like some of his short stories, it didn't "change my life" like some people I've heard of.

I also hear about people who claim to have read The Hobbit or Kim when they were five. Five! And while I started reading before Kindergarten, I wasn't gulping down whole novels when I was five.  Or even having them read out loud to me.

One funny story this reminds me of is when I was talking to a precocious fourth grader my wife had.  We were talking about books and somehow Ender's Game came up in conversation, so he went off, read it, and told me about this achievement.  I said, "Well, I 'm glad you enjoyed it.  That might be a good book to revisit when you're a little older.  You might find you get more out of it."

He came up to me the next year, when he was in fifth grade and said, "You were so right about me re-reading Ender's Game.  I got so much more out of it now that I'm older."

1 comment:

Ms. Yingling said...

My son read all of Tolkien in third grade but didn't tell me. He's read them again and does admit he missed a lot. I read The Hobbit when my friends pressured me to in the 7th grade, but it took me until I was 35 to finish the series! I'm never impressed by students who read stuff that is too old for them.